Should Public and Private Schools Have Separate Athletic Postseasons?

[ravensfan09]

Don't try equating private schools and open enrollment public schools. They're still two very different animals and play by very different rules.

Private schools have some inherent advantages to attracting top notch athletes. Because of those advantages they often don't need to recruit to secure those athletes. That's just the reality of the situation.

I'd hate to see separate tournaments. But the field is no where near even that's for sure.

The problem is the OHSAA is trying to use competitive balance to even the playing field, but the private schools sue the OHSAA because they lose the advantage.

[79Tiger]

Ravensfan: Competitive balance has not even been passed so how are private schools suing over something that does not exist yet? If you can cite a case, please post it. Meanwhile, here is the latest on round 3 of the proposed competitive balance by the OHSAA. Versions 1 & 2 were voted down.The deadline for the school principal's to vote is on Wednesday 5-13-19. The date of the article is 5-8-19. http://highschoolsports.cleveland.com/n ... ast-votes/

[one Oak]

The article is dated 2013.

[Orange and Brown]

for

Ravensfan: Competitive balance has not even been passed so how are private schools suing over something that does not exist yet? If you can cite a case, please post it. Meanwhile, here is the latest on round 3 of the proposed competitive balance by the OHSAA. Versions 1 & 2 were voted down.The deadline for the school principal's to vote is on Wednesday 5-13-19. The date of the article is 5-8-19. http://highschoolsports.cleveland.com/n ... ast-votes/

CB has been around for a couple of years. They are making some changes for it this year.

[NYBuckeye96]

Nelsonville-York vs. Private Schools
19 games played

Record: 7-12


Columbus Academy
Academy leads all-time series 1 win, 0 losses
2006 Columbus Academy (#H) 55-21

Columbus Bishop Ready
NY leads all-time series 3 wins, 1 loss
1991 Nelsonville-York (H) 20-14
2007 Bishop Ready (A) 47-0
2010 Nelsonville-York (H) 26-16
2011 Nelsonville-York (A) 47-13

Columbus St. Charles
St. Charles leads all-time series 2 wins, 0 losses
1999 St. Charles (A) 35-7
2000 St. Charles (H) 19-6


Newark Catholic
Newark Catholic leads all-time series 5 wins, 3 losses
2010 Newark Catholic (H) 13-9
2011 Nelsonville-York (A) 34-12
2012 Newark Catholic (H) 32-6
2013 Newark Catholic (A) 34-16
2014 Nelsonville-York (H) 9-0
2015 Newark Catholic (A) 27-26 OT
2016 Newark Catholic (H) 41-21
2017 Nelsonville-York (A) 21-14

Zanesville Rosecrans
Rosecrans leads all-time series 3 wins, 1 loss
1970 Rosecrans (A) 27-0
1971 Rosecrans (H) 35-13
1972 Rosecrans (A) 18-13
1973 Nelsonville-York (H) 60-0

[79Tiger]

for

Ravensfan: Competitive balance has not even been passed so how are private schools suing over something that does not exist yet? If you can cite a case, please post it. Meanwhile, here is the latest on round 3 of the proposed competitive balance by the OHSAA. Versions 1 & 2 were voted down.The deadline for the school principal's to vote is on Wednesday 5-13-19. The date of the article is 5-8-19. http://highschoolsports.cleveland.com/n ... ast-votes/

CB has been around for a couple of years. They are making some changes for it this year.

CB has been voted down twice according to the article

[Orange and Brown]

for

Ravensfan: Competitive balance has not even been passed so how are private schools suing over something that does not exist yet? If you can cite a case, please post it. Meanwhile, here is the latest on round 3 of the proposed competitive balance by the OHSAA. Versions 1 & 2 were voted down.The deadline for the school principal's to vote is on Wednesday 5-13-19. The date of the article is 5-8-19. http://highschoolsports.cleveland.com/n ... ast-votes/

CB has been around for a couple of years. They are making some changes for it this year.

CB has been voted down twice according to the article

You do realize this article is 6 years old?

[91blue14]

should a kid be able to go to school where he/she wants to? there is probably not a wrong answer but being American I like my freedom