Is this a touchdown?

[2trap_4ever]

found this online, doesn't look like his feet are in, just wondering http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BWJF8L5O3HE&feature=related

[OZZIEOHIO]

NO WAY!!!

[wobycat]

NO WAY!!!

Go to Burgfan.com you will see that your wrong!

[buckfan84]

looked like his foot landed in before falling out of bounds.

[OZZIEOHIO]

I seen it from another angle on here and he jugled the ball after his feet hit the ground. It was on here somewhere.

[buckeyeshots]

After being at the game that night, I was kind of skeptical of the call on the field until i got home that night. This video has been up since the night of that game. If you pause the video at the right moment (and it took me like 20 tries to do it) you can see that he clearly has a foot in bounds (his toe i might add, but thats all it takes.) The juggling can say nothing about and i don't believe that anybody can say anything about that from just this video.

The long and short of it is that it was a touchdown. This is coming from a completely unbiased photographer.

[OZZIEOHIO]

I had to look at it a bunch of times also. It doesnt matter the Ref made the decision at game time speed. It would be hard to argue with out all the videos.

[YOU'RE TIGER BAIT]

TILL MY DYING BREATH NO. APPEARS POSSIBLY FOOT IN , BUT BOBBLING BALL. ON OTHER CLIP I SAW.

[YOU'RE TIGER BAIT]

NO WAY!!!

Go to Burgfan.com you will see that your wrong!

---------------- foot questionable, ball not in possession.

[Burg_Grad_77]

Get over it people!!!!

That was 9 weeks ago and it was called a TD. Also, if you go to BurgFan.com you can view the video from the angle looking straight down the line and he is clearly in and did not bobble the ball.

Jeez, you Ironton people just can't accept the fact that you lost to poor little ole Wheelersburg again.

GET A LIFE!!!!!!

[Burg_Grad_77]

The video on here proves without a doubt he catches the ball and is in bounds. Anyone who can't see that is just fooling themselves.

http://football.burgfan.com/videos.htm

[YOU'RE TIGER BAIT]

like i said EASY TOUCHDOWN.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- call me a fool then, don't think he had possession. but way too close for a ref to call, in real speed.

[100 percent]

When looking at from different angles and speeds, it is definitely a TD.

[tigermama]

An Ironton poster didn't introduce this topic

[tl895]

easy call from the second video td

[BubbleGumTiger]

An Ironton poster didn't introduce this topic

A very good observation Mama........


the pup had a good game Friday nite.....

[NYBUX]

NO doubt................6 points

[earp]

I used to work with that side judge that was part of that call and I will tell you they are one of the better crews in our area! I think they always try to let the kids decide the game,From what I could see the foot is definetly down!The only question would be did he have control of the ball,Its just such a bang bang play its hard to tell!

[ItownHosscat]

After further review....

Ive had Pirate fans apologize to me for that call.

[Burg_Grad_77]

After further review....

Ive had Pirate fans apologize to me for that call.

Then they are fools and I would tell them that myself to their face if I knew who they were.

Anyone who watches that video on BurgFan.com and can't see that he clearly has his foot inbounds, by a couple of inches at least, and clearly catches the ball with two hand and cradles it to his body as he is going down is blind as a bat. Both officials that were right on top of the play immediately call it a TD, so they had no doubts it was a good catch, but the telling thing in this entire scenario is that drrabbit, who was right there within a couple of feet of the catch, said it was obviously a good catch. I know some of you are going to say that she is from the Burg and that's why, but I've know her for many years and she is not the type of person to lie about something like that. She would tell it just like it is and if it wasn't a catch she would be the first to say so and have no qualms about saying it. She is a person of very high integrity and I trust her opinion 100%.