who got the better trade?

[The_Legend_of_Northwest]

did the reds when they got edison volquez who leads the majors in strikeouts with 52 and leads the NL in era at 1.06

or the rangers with josh hamilton who leads the majors with 36 rbi's and is about the only thing to cheer for on that team

[TrojanXplosion]

I think that the Reds got the better deal in the long run. Volquez is a very talented pitcher and the Reds really needed another good pitcher. He is even more valuable right now because he is the only pitcher winning any games for us. I mean, Arroyo cant even make it out of the first inning. Volquez is really keeping this team from sliding down to far.

[oak hill71]

Honestly I think Volquez was the better of the two, mainly because Hamilton was just one drug use away from ruining his career.

[TrojanXplosion]

Honestly I think Volquez was the better of the two, mainly because Hamilton was just one drug use away from ruining his career.

Thats not right. The guy beat out a cocaine addiction and his drug using days are done. Your post makes no sense at all.

[Tartanblue]

The Reds because they needed pitching and it wins games.....Hamilton is doing great but has to help and him being the only one hitting will not help the Rangers win games

[cant stop this]

I think the Reds did becasue over the past few years there pitching has been horrible. There offense will pick up and score some runs. Pitching wins games so the Reds got the better deal.

[OZZIEOHIO]

Ill go with the reds also, You can find good batters easier then good pitchers.

[someoverkill]

everyone is one drug abuse episode from the end. What a dip. Hamilton is a great person.

[BigMcCauley55]

the reds pitching has improved alot and he has helped out alot Harang cant do it all by himself so Ed was a nice addtion

[The_Legend_of_Northwest]

still wish the reds couldve given someone else up instead of hamilton

i would love to have his 44 rbi's

[TrojanXplosion]

still wish the reds couldve given someone else up instead of hamilton

i would love to have his 44 rbi's

Same here but, the way the Reds have played thus far, with the exception of the past few games, Hamiltons 44 RBI'S wouldn't have made much of a difference in our win/loss record. We really needed the pitching and Volquez has answered the call so far.

[Enemy of State_98]

The pitching has been the reds achilles heel for years and they have always had more than enough in the outfield so regardless of what hamilton does the reds got young pitching that could help them for years to come and keep them in alot of games.