All-Time Ohio Team

[schenk11]

Thought this was interesting from the other site. Some local kids making the team, I have them bolded.



When colleague Jon Spencer authored a story about a TV show discussing Ohio's greatest high school football players, it triggered a thought. The thought became an obsession.

The Internet is a wonderful thing with Web sites for the College Football Hall of Fame, the Pro Football Hall of Fame, All-American teams from the past century, and various sources from around the state, particularly in Cleveland, Youngstown, Canton, Akron, Columbus, Cincinnati, Dayton and Toledo.

I used all of them and more, and each led to one conclusion. Ohio has long wielded a cornucopia of high school football talent.

The players making first- and second-team all-time All-Ohio includes offensive and defensive legends, with special team superstars and a huge and stunning honorable mention list.

I could make a spectacular squad from the guys that didn't make this list, and there are more than 180 that did.

I would start with LeBron James, twice an All-Ohio receiver before not playing his senior year. National recruiting analyst Tom Lemming said James would've been the No. 1 prospect in the nation his senior year had he played football. Makes me want to add LeBron as an addendum.

One Heisman Trophy winner, Troy Smith, didn't make it. He shared the quarterback job his junior year at Lakewood St. Edward, and completed 42 percent of his passes his senior year at Glenville, not enough to make this team.

Likewise, one No. 1 overall pick in the NFL draft didn't make it, "Big Daddy" Dan Wilkinson was such a high school project out of Dayton he had to redshirt at Ohio State.

Receiver Terry Glenn, who won the Biletnikoff Award at Ohio State, isn't on the team either. He was a walk-on out of Brookhaven, and had a teammate, Marlon Kerner, who was a much better high school player. Kerner isn't here either.

In Mansfield, don't look for Hugh Douglas. The NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year in 1995 wasn't all-conference as a prep performer.

Some kids won Mr. Football and didn't make it.

Two of Grantland Rice's immortal Four Horseman at Notre Dame were from Ohio. Knute Rockne called Don Miller the greatest open field runner he ever coached. Unfortunately, Miller sat the bench and barely played at Defiance High School. Can't have benchwarmers on this team.

The other one, quarterback Harry Stuhldreher, hailed from Massillon, but played his senior year at Kiski Prep in Pennsylvania. He wound up an honorable mention selection because he was a significant player for the Tigers.

Len Dawson is a Pro Football Hall of Famer who was a gunslinger at Alliance in the early 1950s, before the term was applied to quarterbacks. Dawson was ahead of his time, and an honorable-mention pick here, but I simply couldn't rate him ahead of two other superb high school quarterbacks, Art Schlichter and Roger Staubach. That's the kind of competition we're talking about.

Ohio produced out-of-state Heisman Trophy winners at Georgia (Youngstown Chaney's Frank Sinkwich) and Princeton (Maumee's Dick Kazmaier). Both were honorable mention on this list, as was Ohio State's Les Horvath (of Parma) and No. 1 overall NFL draft pick Ki-Jana Carter, from Westerville South.

The toughest choice for me was at running back. My favorite college football player is Archie Griffin. He was Ohio's Class AAA Back of the Year as a senior at Eastmoor, and absolutely deserves to be on this team. However, I couldn't get him on my first team because I couldn't rate Griffin as a better high school back than Keith Byars or Robert Smith.

Vic Janowicz might be the state's greatest all-around player. He could run, pass, kick, play defense, and all at an elite level. Some say he was the best defensive back in Ohio State history, that's why he's in the secondary here.

Same for Chic Harley, who may be Janowicz's only rival in the all-around player department. Perhaps the first true skill-position superstar in Ohio's prep ranks, he fits nicely into the secondary, too.

Pete Henry is probably my favorite player on the first team. A three-time national high school All-American who graduated at Mansfield Senior in 1914, he was a charter member of both the college and pro football halls of fame. Henry was a fearsome two-way lineman and punter (with an NFL record 94-yard boot on his resume). Henry attended Washington & Jefferson College, and when he signed with the Canton Bulldogs it was a Page 1 story in the Canton Repository. Jim Thorpe forming the NFL was on Page 3.

Obviously, Ohio State has long feasted on this array of talent, but Ohio schoolboys have fueled lots of other college programs, too. Michigan, Notre Dame, Penn State, Nebraska, USC, UCLA, Navy, Duke, Toledo, Miami of Ohio and Bucknell all have youngsters on this first or second team.

If you see a name and don't recognize it, Google it, you're probably in for a great story.

I'm from the Newark area and never heard of Tom Hamilton. A 6-foot-1, 180-pound halfback, he's a College Football Hall of Famer thanks to a brilliant career at Navy in the 1920s. Hamilton attended Doane Academy in Granville and became head coach at Navy at age 28. He later served as athletics director for the Midshipmen and eventually at Pittsburgh.

That's a typical tale on this team.

DON'T AGREE?

Obviously, there is no end-of-argument list, and lots of room for discussion. I'm pretty confident in the sources used here, but if you have a beef of why someone should or shouldn't be on the team, or a conflicting source on one of these players, I'd love to hear about it.

Be sure to fire off an e-mail and lend your thoughts on what I hope will be a fun, thought-provoking discussion.

alltimefbohio_mvp

ALL-TIME ALL-OHIO HIGH SCHOOL FOOTBALL TEAM

FIRST TEAM

OFFENSE

QB Art Schlichter, 6-3, 210, Miami Trace, Ohio State

RB Robert Smith, 6-3, 210, Euclid, Ohio State

RB Keith Byars, 6-3, 235, Dayton Roth, Ohio Sate

FB Marion Motley, 6-1, 232, Canton McKinley, South Carolina State

OL Pete Henry, 6-3, 245, Mansfield Senior, Washington & Jefferson

OL Jim Parker, 6-3, 273, Toledo Scott, Ohio State

OL Orlando Pace, 6-6, 330, Sandusky, Ohio State

OL Bob Brown, 6-4, 280, Cleveland East Tech, Nebraska

OL Dan Dierdorf, 6-3, 275, Canton Glenwood, Michigan

TE Kyle Rudolph, 6-7, 245, Cincinnati Elder, Notre Dame

WR Cris Carter, 6-3, 210, Middletown, Ohio State

WR Desmond Howard, 5-10, 185, Cleveland St. Joseph's, Michigan

DEFENSE

DL Bill Willis, 6-2, 213, Columbus East, Ohio State

DL Alan Page, 6-4, 245, Canton Central Catholic, Notre Dame

DL Ross Browner, 6-3, 247, Warren Western Reserve, Notre Dame

DL Jim Houston, 6-2, 216, Massillon, Ohio State

LB Jack Lambert, 6-4, 220, Mantua Crestwood, Kent State

LB Andy Katzenmoyer, 6-4, 245, Westerville South, Ohio State

LB Tom Cousineau, 6-2, 230, Lakewood St. Edward, Ohio State

LB Chris Spielman, 6-1, 225, Massillon, Ohio State

DB Vic Janowicz, 5-9, 185, Elyria, Ohio State

DB Chic Harley, 5-8, 160 Columbus East, Ohio State

DB Charles Woodson, 6-1, 200, Fremont, Michigan

DB George McAfee, 6-0, 178, Ironton, Duke

SPECIAL TEAMS

P Tom Tupa, 6-4, 220, Brecksville, Ohio State

PR Ted Ginn, 5-11, 180, Cleveland Glenville, Ohio State

PR Bam Childress, 5-7, 170, Bedford Chanel, Ohio State

K Lou Groza, Martins Ferry, 6-3, 240, Ohio State

KR Paul Warfield, 6-0, 188, Warren Harding, Ohio State

KR Cliff Battles, 6-1, 194, Akron Kenmore, West Virginia Wesleyan



COACH: Paul Brown, Massillon, 1932-1940, 80-8-2 record, 6 state titles, 4 national titles.

TEAM: Fostoria, 1912 national champions, 8-0 and outscored foes 596-0.



SECOND TEAM

OFFENSE

QB Roger Staubach, 6-2, 190, Cincinnati Purcell, Navy

RB Archie Griffin, 5-8, 180, Columbus Eastmoor, Ohio State

RB Maurice Clarett, 6-0, 230, Warren Harding, Ohio State

FB Larry Csonka, 6-3, 235, Stow, Syracuse

OL Mike Michalske, 6-0, 210, Cleveland W. Tech, Penn State

OL Chris Ward, 6-4, 275, Dayton Patterson, Ohio State

OL John Hicks, 6-3, 258, Cleveland John Hay, Ohio State

OL Jack Cannon, 5-11, 193, Columbus Aquinas, Notre Dame

OL Jim Lachey, 6-6, 294, St. Henry, Ohio State

TE Jim Mandich, 6-2, 224, Solon, Michigan

WR Joey Galloway, 6-0, 170, Bellaire, Ohio State

WR Wes Fesler 5-11, 180, Youngstown South, Ohio State

DEFENSE

DL Gary Jeter, 6-4, 259, Cleveland Cathedral Latin, USC

DL Irv Eatman, 6-7, 293, Dayton Meadowdale, UCLA

DL Jim Marshall, 5-11, 208, Columbus East, Ohio State

DL Mel Long, 6-1, 230, Toledo Macomber, Toledo

LB Jim Lynch, 6-1, 225, Lima Central Catholic, Notre Dame

LB Randy Gradishar, 6-3, 236, Champion, Ohio State

LB Clarke Hinkle, 5-11, 202, Toronto, Bucknell

LB Bob Babich, 6-2, 225, Campbell Memorial, Miami (Ohio)

DB Howard "Hopalong" Cassady, 5-10, 172, Columbus Central, Ohio State

DB Michael Doss, 6-0, 200, Canton McKinley, Ohio State

DB Antoine Winfield, 5-9, 170, Akron Garfield, Ohio State

DB Dave Brown, 6-1, 185, Akron Garfield, Michigan


HONORABLE MENTION

Redgie Arden, Ironton; Gordon Bell, Troy; Ted Bell, Youngstown Mooney; Todd Bell, Middletown; LeCharles Bentley, Cleveland St. Ignatius; Alex Boone, Lakewood St. Edward; Aaron Brown, Warren Western Reserve; Harold Brown, Kent Roosevelt; Fred Bruney, Martins Ferry; Bob Brudzinski, Fremont Ross; Hubert Bobo, Chauncey-Dover; Rob Carpenter, Lancaster; Ki-Jana Carter, Westerville South; Chris Chambers, Bedford; Matt Christopher, Lake; Nate Clements, Shaker Heights; Ollie Cline, Fredericktown; Bob Crable, Cincinnati Moeller; Tom Curtis, Aurora; Pete Cusik, Lakewood St. Edward; Thom Darden, Sandusky; Tim Davis, Warren Western Reserve; Len Dawson, Alliance; Van Ness DeCree, Warren Western Reserve; Tom DeLeone, Kent; Doug Donley, Cambridge; Bob Dove, Youngstown South; Marc Edwards, Norwood; Ray Eichenlaub, Columbus East; Curtis Enis, Mississinawa Valley.

Bob Ferguson, Troy; Dave Foley, Cincinnati Roger Bacon; Tim Fox, Canton Glenwood; Hiawatha Francisco, Cincinnati Moeller; Simon Fraser, Upper Arlington; Dennis Franklin, Massillon; Benny Friedman, Cleveland E. Tech; Ken Fritz, Ironton; Dave Gallagher, Piqua; Elvis Grbac, Cleveland St. Joseph's; Ray Griffin, Columbus Eastmoor; Ralph Gugliemi, Grandview Heights; Anthony Gonzalez, Cleveland St. Ignatius; Bill Hackett, London; Antonio Hall, Canton McKinley; Tom Hamilton, Granville Doane Academy; Jeff Hartings, St. Henry; John Havlicek, Bridgeport; Chuck Heater, Tiffin; Erick Howard, North Canton Hoover; Buster Howe, Zanesville; Les Horvath, Parma; Bob Hoying, St. Henry; Tony Hunter, Cincinnati Moeller; Mike Ingram, Bellaire; Joe Johnson, Fostoria; Chuck Jones, Chillicothe; Gomer Jones, Cleveland South; Dick Kazmaier, Maumee; Dwight Kelley, Bremen; Rex Kern, Lancaster; Bernie Kosar, Boardman; Ken Kuhn, Louisville; Dante Lavelli, Hudson; Dave Leggett, New Philadelphia; Jeff Logan, North Canton Hoover; Rob Lytle, Fremont Ross; Dick Mack, Bucyrus.

Tom Mack, Cleveland Heights; Willie Mack, Mansfield Senior; Nick Mangold, Kettering Alter; Mario Manningham, Warren Harding; Marcus Marek, Masury; Jim Martin, Cleveland East Tech, Johnny Mattress, Cincinnati Princeton; Ben Mauk, Kenton; Rufus Mayes, Toledo Macomber; Napoleon McCallum, Millford; O.J. McDuffie, Gates Mills Hawken; Dee Miller, Springfield South; Rip Miller, Canton McKinley; Damon Moore, Fostoria; Michael Munoz, Cincinnati Moeller; Steve Myers, Kenton; Mike Nugent, Centerville; Ray Nolting, Cincinnati Hughes; Jim Otis, Celina; Joe Pickens, Cleveland St. Ignatius; Ahmed Plummer, Cincinnati Wyoming; Larry Poole, Akron Garfield; Ricky Powers, Akron Buchtel; Omar Provitt, Warren Harding; Ray Pryor, Hamilton; Brady Quinn, Dublin Coffman; Javon Ringer, Dayton Chaminade-Julienne; Robbie Robertson, Barberton; Ben Roethlisberger, Findlay; Esco Sarkkinen, Fairport Harbor; Don Scott, Canton McKinley; Mike Sensibaugh, Lockland; Kurt Shumacher, Lorain; Frank Sinkwich, Youngstown Chaney; Inwood Smith, Mansfield Senior

Carlos Snow, Cincinnati Academy of Physical Education; Percy Snow, Canton McKinley; Tim Spencer, St. Clairsvillle; Frank Stams, Akron St. Vincent-St. Mary's; Pete Stinchcomb, Fostoria; Steve Strinko, Middletown; Korey Stringer, Warren Harding; Dana Stubblefield, North Bend Taylor; Harry Stuhldreher, Massillon; Tyrrel Sutton, Akron Hoban; Billy Taylor, Barberton; Bob Timberlake, Franklin; Steve Tovar, Elyria; Aurelius Thomas, Columbus West; Jim Tyrer, Newark; Jeff Uhlenhake, Newark Catholic; Garin Veris, Chillicothe; Richard Volk, Wauseon; Mike Vrabel, Walsh Jesuit; Chris Wells, Akron Garfield; Chuck Webb, Toledo Macomber; Merle Wendt, Middletown; Gary Williams, Wilmington; Larry Zelina, Cleveland Benedictine; Trent Zenkewicz, Cleveland St. Ignatius; Mike Zordich, Youngstown Chaney; Justin Zwick, Massillon.

[Orange and Brown]

What a crock!

[schenk11]

What a crock!

Why? Just curious why you think the team is a crock. Looks pretty good to me, just thought it was interesting to look at all the names.

[Orange and Brown]

What a crock!

Why? Just curious why you think the team is a crock. Looks pretty good to me, just thought it was interesting to look at all the names.

Because it is the all Columbus,Cincinnati, Cleveland list.

Hubie Bobo honorable mention? Really? He should at least be 2nd team.

[Matt52]

archie griffen 2nd team really?

[Rocket50]

AJ Hawk anyone? Cmon man he's at least 2nd team, Mike Doss- Best safety to ever play for the buckeyes?

[lhsfan97]

Glad to see two players from Lancaster made it anywhere on the list. Carpenter and Kern were both great high school athletes as well as college athletes and Carpenter had a good NFL career as well. Kern's NFL career was cut short due to injury but was a good defensive back

Rex Kern was probably the best athlete in Lancaster history. He was a high school all american in football, basketball, and baseball. Although he went to play football at Ohio State he was drafted by Kansas City to play baseball straight out of high school and was also offered basketball scholarships from Ohio, Ohio State, North Carolina, and UCLA.

[schenk11]

AJ Hawk anyone? Cmon man he's at least 2nd team, Mike Doss- Best safety to ever play for the buckeyes?

According to the article it is based on HS accomplishments and performance not anything after that.

[Run Bubba Run]

Schenk11,

I appreciate your effort in naming the teams. There will be eternal arguments about this guy or that guy. The only complaint I have is that you have 12 players on offense and 12 on defense. With all the decisions you had to make, I am surprised that you could not stick with just 11 each. Just a thought.

[Orange and Brown]

Schenk11,

I appreciate your effort in naming the teams. There will be eternal arguments about this guy or that guy. The only complaint I have is that you have 12 players on offense and 12 on defense. With all the decisions you had to make, I am surprised that you could not stick with just 11 each. Just a thought.

Schenk11 didn't do this. This was done for Ohio High Magazine or something. you can also find it on the OHSAA site to. The guy wrote one for baseball to.

[boilermaker]

Larry Csonka second team? LOL He was the best FB ever let alone Ohio! True Fullback!

[BuckeyeNink]

Chuck Ealy not even being honorable mention is absurd.

[yellowjacket]

if it is based on highschool only ben mauk passed for over 17,000 yards and tyrell sutton rushed for over 9,000 yards they would have to be 1st team and not honorable mention.

[oldtrojan]

Chuck Ealy not even being honorable mention is absurd.

Saw Chuck and the Notre Dame Titans play every home game at Spartan Stadium his junior and senior years. What an incedible talent.

Also think you should have taken a very long, hard look at one Curtis Gentry, from the Portsmouth High School TROJANS.

[datchillicav]

This is a pretty good list. It's based on what they did in high school. Not whether they were any good in college or the pros.

Schenk: Chillicothe has two players on the list that are not bolded. Are we not SEO enough to be considered??? Lol. Cmon man.